The History of Terrorism
Preview
Open in TheBrain
Allen Frances
At 40 minutes and 45 seconds of Psychiatry & Big Pharma: Exposed
Attachments
Psychiatry & Big Pharma: Exposed
wikipedia
Parents
1754-Today Columbia College (New York)
1980 DSM-III
American psychiatrists
Duke University School of Medicine faculty
Psychiatry controversies
SUNY Downstate Medical Center
Children
...Yet despite that conservatism (I let the comment slip), we learnt some pretty tough lessons - we learned overall that even if you make minimal changes to the DSM, the way the world uses the manual is not always the way you intended it be used. ...
1986-Today Journal of Personality Disorders
1994 DSM-IV
1995-Today Journal of Psychiatric Practice
2019 TWU - Psychiatry & Big Pharma: Exposed - Dr James Davies, PhD
ADHD (Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder)
Asperger syndrome (AS)
Bipolar II disorder
But one of the problems with proceeding in that way, is that it assumes the DSM system you inherited from Spitzer was fit for purpose. ...
Can you put a figure on how many people have been wrongly medicalized? (James Davies question to Allen Frances)
Exactly.
For instance, we added Bipolar II, Asperger's disorder, and finally we added ADHD. And well these decissions helped promote three false epidemics in psychiatry.
If we were going to either add new diagnoses or eliminate existing ones there had to be substantial scientific evidence to support that decision. And there simply wasn't. ...
In other words, (corrected Frances) it felt better to stabilize the existing arbitrary decisions than to create a whole assorment of new ones.
So you are essentially saying that you set out to stabilize the arbitrary decisions that were made during the construction of DSM-III? (James Davies question to Allen Frances)
The Task Force (board of DSM-IV)
We did not assume that at all. We knew that everything that came before was arbitrary (Frances quickly corrects himself), we knew that most decisions that came before were arbitrary. ...
Well we now have a rate of autism that is twenty times what it was fifteen years ago. ...
Well, the first thing I have to say about that is that DSM-IV was a remarkably unambitious and modest effort to stabilize psychiatric diagnosis, and not to create new problems. ...
What do you mean by that? (James Davies question to Allen Frances)
Jumps
James Davies (PhD)