Holloway Carson Clmntster
===
mma 10 24 OMG
Project 2025 partner blog advocates for overturning New York Times Co. v. Sullivan
The Claremont Institute's American Mind: “President Trump should make the case for revisiting the Sullivan ruling a more prominent and recurring part of his public rhetoric”
Written by Madeline Peltz
:{Published 10/25/24
The American Mind, a project of Project 2025 partner The Claremont Institute, published a piece on October 23 advocating for a second Trump administration to seek the Supreme Court to overturn New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, a key decision protecting the First Amendment.
Legal scholars have described the Sullivan decision, which established the “actual malice” standard in libel law, as “one of the Supreme Court’s most significant First Amendment rulings.” As Oyez outlines: “When a statement concerns a public figure, the Court held, it is not enough to show that it is false for the press to be liable for libel. Instead, the target of the statement must show that it was made with knowledge of or reckless disregard for its falsity.”
The Claremont Institute’s Carson Holloway recently argued that “President Trump should seek the reversal of New York Times v. Sullivan,” casting his argument as a continuation of the Dobbs decision that reversed the constitutional right to abortion. Holloway celebrates Trump as singularly responsible for Dobbs, describing it as his “signature accomplishment” in his “already impressive legacy” of the “restoration of self-government.” Continued:
If Trump is elected to a second term, he should build on this legacy by seeking the reversal of another egregious instance of judicial activism that continues to distort the Constitution and our nation’s politics: New York Times v. Sullivan. In this 1964 ruling, the Warren Court imposed a new doctrine of libel and the First Amendment on the nation.
Holloway then lays out a three point plan for how to accomplish this.
First, he suggests, “President Trump should make the case for revisiting the Sullivan ruling a more prominent and recurring part of his public rhetoric.” He has good reason to believe this is viable. In 2016, Trump promised that if he won he would “open up our libel laws” to make it easier to sue the press, singling out The New York Times and The Washington Post. On the Supreme Court, Justices Thomas and Gorsuch have both signaled their openness to reconsidering Sullivan.
More recently, Trump has been ramping up his attacks on journalists, advocating for revoking broadcasting licenses and launching other legal attacks. Brendan Carr, a Trump-appointed member of the Federal Communications Commission that oversees broadcasting licenses, could be a key ally in this threat. Carr wrote the chapter on the FCC in Project 2025’s policy book, Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise.
Holloway’s next suggestion on stripping the press of legal protections is a given: “President Trump should continue his first-term policy of appointing serious constitutionalists to the Supreme Court and, indeed, to all federal judicial vacancies.”
Finally, Holloway states: “President Trump should direct his Department of Justice to seek the reversal of the actual malice doctrine and restore judicial respect for the original meaning of the First Amendment. This policy should include the regular filing, in appropriate cases, of amicus curiae briefs by the Justice Department urging the courts to revisit this question.”
This argument harmonizes with the vision of a weaponized Department of Justice outlined in Mandate. As Gene Hamilton, vice president and general counsel of former Project 2025 partner America First Legal, wrote in his chapter on the Justice Department, DOJ policy “must always be consistent with the President’s policy agenda and the rule of law.” Project 2025 would gut the federal government’s system of checks and balances through a radical consolidation of executive power.
Project 2025’s emphasis on personnel would also bolster a second Trump administration’s attacks on free speech. Through the initiative, The Heritage Foundation has assembled a prevetted database of Trump loyalists, which it calls a “conservative LinkedIn,” of potential administration hires that have taken loyalty tests to prove they’d be willing to stretch or even violate the law in order to enact his agenda. Project 2025 also advocates for the implementation of a policy known as “Schedule F,” which would remove civil service protections for politically neutral career bureaucrats so they could be fired en masse and replaced with pro-MAGA sycophants. Remaking the federal workforce in this way would allow Trump to more easily exercise control over the Department of Justice and enact a retributional, anti-free speech agenda.
===
offbs
Carson Holloway
Washington Fellow
Carson Holloway is a Washington Fellow at The Claremont Institute’s Center for the American Way of Life. His research focuses on American constitutionalism and the liberal nationalism of the American Founding.
He is Ralph Wardle Diamond Professor of Arts and Sciences and Professor of Political Science at University of Nebraska, Omaha. He has been a Visiting Fellow in Princeton University’s James Madison Program in American Ideals and Institutions and a Visiting Fellow in American Political Thought at The Heritage Foundation.
He is co-editor, with Bradford P. Wilson, of the two-volume work The Political Writings of Alexander Hamilton (Cambridge University Press, 2017). He is also the author of Hamilton versus Jefferson in the Washington Administration: Completing the Founding or Betraying the Founding? (Cambridge University Press, 2015).
His scholarly articles have appeared in the Review of Politics, Interpretation: A Journal of Political Philosophy, and Perspectives on Political Science, and he has written more popular articles for The Wall Street Journal, First Things, The New Criterion, National Affairs, Law & Liberty, Public Discourse, The Federalist, and National Review.
Professor Holloway received his B.A. from the University of Northern Iowa and his Ph.D. from Northern Illinois University.
Articles by Carson Holloway
Article June 14, 2024
The Prudence of Presidential Immunity
Carson Holloway](https://dc.claremont.org/the-prudence-of-presidential-immunity/)[
Article June 5, 2024
Americans Must Criticize Our Corrupt Courts
Carson Holloway](https://dc.claremont.org/americans-must-criticize-our-corrupt-courts/)[
Article February 27, 2024
Morally Empty
Carson Holloway](https://dc.claremont.org/morally-empty/)[
Article January 20, 2024
Democracy Without Politics
Carson Holloway](https://dc.claremont.org/democracy-without-politics/)[
Article October 19, 2023
Righting the Right
Carson Holloway](https://dc.claremont.org/righting-the-right/)[
Article March 10, 2023
The New York Times Versus Florida
Carson Holloway](https://dc.claremont.org/the-new-york-times-versus-florida/)[
Article January 20, 2023
Trump Takes Aim at New York Times v. Sullivan
Carson Holloway](https://dc.claremont.org/trump-takes-aim-at-new-york-times-v-sullivan/)[
Article January 3, 2023
Christmas and Western Civilization
Carson Holloway](https://dc.claremont.org/christmas-and-western-civilization/)[
Article December 21, 2022
CNN Admits to Being a Propaganda Operation
Carson Holloway](https://dc.claremont.org/cnn-admits-to-being-a-propaganda-operation/)[
Article December 20, 2022
Malice Toward All, Defamation for None?
Carson Holloway](https://dc.claremont.org/malice-toward-all-defamation-for-none/)
ggl 10 24
carson holloway claremeont trump
Search Results
[### Constitutionalist-in-Chief
The American Mind
https://americanmind.org › features › constitutionalist-in-...](https://americanmind.org/features/what-trump-should-do-if-he-wins/constitutionalist-in-chief/)
2 days ago — Constitutionalist-in-Chief. Carson Holloway. President Donald Trump Attacks The FBI And Media. President Trump should seek the reversal of New ...
[### Project 2025 partner blog advocates for overturning New ...
Media Matters for America
https://www.mediamatters.org › justice-civil-liberties › pr...](https://www.mediamatters.org/justice-civil-liberties/project-2025-partner-blog-advocates-overturning-new-york-times-co-v)
5 hours ago — The Claremont Institute's American Mind: “President Trump should make the case for revisiting the Sullivan ruling a more prominent and ...
[### Carson Holloway, Author at The American Way of Life The Claremont Institute
https://dc.claremont.org › author › carson-holloway](https://dc.claremont.org/author/carson-holloway/)
He is Ralph Wardle Diamond Professor of Arts and Sciences and Professor of Political Science at University of Nebraska, Omaha. He has been a Visiting Fellow in ...
[### Carson Holloway, Author at Law & Liberty
Law & Liberty
https://lawliberty.org › author › carson-holloway](https://lawliberty.org/author/carson-holloway/)
Judge Kurt D. Engelhardt's opinion has much to teach us about the principles that govern law and politics in a constitutional republic. Machiavelli.
[### Carson Holloway
Public Discourse
https://www.thepublicdiscourse.com › author › cholloway](https://www.thepublicdiscourse.com/author/cholloway/)
A timely book on the thought of Harry Jaffa and Walter Berns reminds us that patriotism needs to be about ideas and principles, but it cannot only be about ...
[### The Secretive Billionaire Network Funding 'Stop the Steal' 2.0
WSJ
https://www.wsj.com › Politics › Elections](https://www.wsj.com/politics/elections/donald-trump-contest-election-outcome-4521f4f7)
3 days ago — GOP donors have given more than $140 million to nearly 50 groups working on election integrity; 'another crusade of ours'
[### Democracy Without Politics
The American Mind
https://americanmind.org › salvo › democracy-without-p...](https://americanmind.org/salvo/democracy-without-politics/)
Jan 18, 2024 — President Biden delivers primetime address to nation on next phase of pandemic. The Left seeks to overturn the 2024 election even before it happens.
[### The Prudence of Presidential Immunity The Claremont Institute
https://dc.claremont.org › the-prudence-of-presidential-i...](https://dc.claremont.org/the-prudence-of-presidential-immunity/)
Jun 14, 2024 — The contemporary American Left is willing to go full scorched earth to win every tactical advantage, without thinking about the long-term ...
[### Americans Must Criticize Our Corrupt Courts: Holloway The Maine Wire
https://www.themainewire.com › News › Commentary](https://www.themainewire.com/2024/06/americans-must-criticize-our-corrupt-courts-holloway/)
Jun 10, 2024 — Criticism of the justice system when it errs or overreaches is necessary to preserving freedom under the rule of law.
[### Thinking Bigly
Claremont Review of Books
https://claremontreviewofbooks.com › thinking-bigly](https://claremontreviewofbooks.com/thinking-bigly/)
Reading the two-volume set Trump and Political Philosophy, I was reminded of an oft-cited (in certain circles) remark of Xenophon's Socrates, ...