salesforce benioff
TEMP AGENCY IS EXTRACTION?
---
PAYWALL
The A-List Turned on Marc Benioff. Now He’s Sorry.
The Salesforce CEO apologized for his comments on the National Guard
By
Follow
Oct. 17, 2025
Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff apologizedfor calling on the National Guard to go to San Francisco after a crescendo of rebukes from the city’s political and tech elite he has counted as friends.
“Having listened closely to my fellow San Franciscans and our local officials,” he said Friday, “I do not believe the National Guard is needed to address safety in San Francisco.”
---
SG GATE
NO LNX
FILE: Marc Benioff attends a Time magazine event on October 24, 2023 in New York City.
Marc Benioff’s newly public support for President Donald Trump isn’t just gum-flapping. Salesforce, the CEO’s gigantic San Francisco company, has reportedly been lobbying Immigration and Customs Enforcement to try and win a contract — and use artificial intelligence to help ICE dramatically expand its violent crackdown.
It’s a revelation that comes amid a wave of attention on Benioff, who recanted his recently espoused support for sending the National Guard into San Francisco in a post to X on Friday. He wrote that he no longer supports it: “My earlier comment came from an abundance of caution around the [Dreamforce] event, and I sincerely apologize for the concern it caused.”
The New York Times, on Thursday, published leaks that Salesforce did not contest. The documentation shows a multi-pronged effort by the company to aid ICE in conducting the raids, abductions and deportations that have become the cornerstone of Trump's anti-immigration campaign. A Salesforce memo to the agency, sent Aug. 26, reportedly described it as an “ideal platform” to help ICE meet its “talent acquisition” goal: “nearly triple its work force by hiring 10,000 new officers and agents expeditiously.”
In the same memo, Salesforce pledged that it could help ICE, “identify, engage and acquire the talent profile proven to drive ICE mission success, and in turn, administration priorities,” the Times reported. Chatting in an ICE-focused internal Slack channel about the pitch, a Salesforce employee reportedly wrote that the document was “out the door,” and got a chorus of praise: fire emojis, an “amazing” and an, “I wish you the best of luck with this one!”
It isn’t clear what the contract would be worth, or whether Salesforce is on track to win it. Neither the company nor the Department of Homeland Security, which oversees ICE, responded to SFGATE’s request for comment. But the Times also reported that Salesforce has brainstormed ideas about how the company’s artificial intelligence agents could help the agency vet tips and aid investigations, and that it has a spreadsheet of possible ICE contracts, dubbed “opportunities.” The spreadsheet reportedly listed some contracts with ICE that are already completed.
While the Times pointed out that Salesforce worked with the agency during the Obama and Biden administrations, and that it works with other government departments, the attempt to serve ICE’s rapid expansion comes amid a new directive for the agency. Trump and the Republican-led Congress, this summer, gave ICE an additional $30 billion for arrest and deportation efforts — including hiring — and $45 billion for detentions. The flood of cash comes as Trump and other administration officials pressure ICE to make far more arrests, including with a daily quota. As of a September story from the Guardian, the agency had already detained or deported more than 44,000 immigrants.
Federal law enforcement agents confront demonstrators outside of an immigrant processing center on September 27, 2025 in Broadview, Illinois. They were protesting a recent surge in ICE apprehensions in the Chicago area.
The upending of American life has rippled outward across families, communities and industries as ICE turns aggression into a week-to-week norm. The stories are grim and abundant: the worker who fell during an ICE raid in Southern California and later died, the Chicago-area pastor shot with a pepper spray ball, three deaths in ICE custody in 12 days and a Mexican immigrant shot and killed during a traffic stop. An expansion of ICE’s workforce, with Salesforce’s aid or without, would enable raids across a much broader swath of the country.
Benioff, who owns Time magazine, told the New York Times last week that he had not closely followed news about immigration raids, in an interview where he also said, “I fully support the president. I think he’s doing a great job.”
Unsurprisingly, the perspective landed him in hot water. Ron Conway, a famed Silicon Valley venture capitalist, has reportedly left the nonprofit Salesforce Foundation’s board because of Benioff’s call, in that Times interview, for National Guard troops to act as San Francisco police. Conway wrote, per reports, that he was “shocked and disappointed” by the comments and “by [Benioff’s] willful ignorance and detachment from the impacts of the ICE immigration raids of families with NO criminal record.”
Laurene Powell Jobs also sounded off against Benioff in a Thursday op-ed published by the Wall Street Journal. The philanthropist and investor skewered the CEO’s boasts about his donations to the city, and accused him of giving to get “a license to impose one’s will. It’s a kind of moral laundering, where so-called benevolence masks self-interest.”
The backlash appears to have gotten through, as Benioff’s Friday apology on X, a day after the company's 2025 Dreamforce conference ended, depicted a chastised CEO. He wrote: “Having listened closely to my fellow San Franciscans and our local officials, and after the largest and safest Dreamforce in our history, I do not believe the National Guard is needed to address safety in San Francisco.”
Benioff, in years past, has been a well-known contributor to progressive causes, including a tax on San Francisco corporations to contribute to funding for homelessness services. He’s also been a major advocate of “business as a platform for change,” touting donations and his company’s policy of pledging 1% of worker time toward equity and sustainability.
Got a tip? Send us the scoop.
But with his statements to the Times and the outlet’s ICE reporting, that public image quickly evaporated. Benioff’s original National Guard comments prompted a wave of irritation from local officials, who sought to balance Salesforce’s economic benefits to the city with the unpopular idea of outside troops, which Trump supported at a press conference on Wednesday. There’s no doubt that Benioff’s update on X brought a sigh of relief.
San Francisco Supervisor Shamann Walton, who represents District 10, said in a statement to SFGATE on Friday, before Benioff’s apology: “I think it is sad that someone who once held progressive values, supported our SFUSD schools and fought to address homelessness, has now become someone who supports tyranny and has become a voice for bashing our beautiful city.”
Work at Salesforce or another Bay Area tech company and want to talk? Contact tech reporter Stephen Council securely at stephen.council@sfgate.com or on Signal at 628-204-5452.
---
GGL 10 25
5:35
YouTube · ABC7 News Bay Area
Salesforce fallout: Marc Benioff offers AI tech for ICE hiring
YouTube · ABC7 News Bay Area
1 day ago
Salesforce CEO Mark Benioff's controversial statements at Dreamforce, including pitching AI tech to ICE for hiring and supporting the National Guard in SF, have caused backlash.
2:05
YouTube · KTVU FOX 2 San Francisco
Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff faces new controversy over ICE ...
YouTube · KTVU FOX 2 San Francisco
2 days ago
Salesforce CEO Mark Benioff's alleged offer to help the federal government hire immigration enforcement agents sparks controversy.
2:29
YouTube · ABC7 News Bay Area
Salesforce fallout: Benioff says he no longer believes National ...
YouTube · ABC7 News Bay Area
1 day ago
Salesforce CEO Mark Benioff is under fire for allegedly trying to win a contract with ICE to triple its staff using AI.
45:13
YouTube · Salesforce
A Conversation with Marc Benioff and David Sacks ...
YouTube · Salesforce
18 hours ago
Feedback
View all
Top stories
ABC7 San Francisco
Salesforce fallout: Benioff says he no longer believes National Guard is needed in San Francisco, issues apology after backlash
1 day ago
The New York Times
Salesforce Offers Its Services to Boost Trump’s Immigration Force
2 days ago
KTVU
Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff faces new controversy over ICE
2 days ago
BBC
Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff apologises for San Francisco deployment remark
1 day ago
More news
Salesforce Offers Its Services to Boost Trump's Immigration ...
The New York Times
https://www.nytimes.com › salesforce-benioff-ice
3 days ago — Marc Benioff, the chief executive of Salesforce, shocked San Franciscans last week when he said that he “fully supports” President Trump and ...
Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff faces new controversy over ICE
KTVU
https://www.ktvu.com › news › new-salesforce-ceo-mar...
2 days ago — Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff is facing new controversy following a report that he offered to help the federal government hire immigration ...
Missing: RECRUIT | Show results with: RECRUIT
Salesforce told ICE it could help speed up hiring of officers
San Francisco Chronicle
https://www.sfchronicle.com › Tech
3 days ago — Screenshots of internal documents and communications obtained by the New York Times show how Benioff pitched ICE on rapidly hiring 10,000 new ...
Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff apologises for San Francisco ...
BBC
https://www.bbc.com › news › articles
2 days ago — Salesforce boss Marc Benioff apologised Friday for suggesting that US President Donald Trump should send National Guard troops to San ...
Missing: RECRUIT | Show results with: RECRUIT
Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff took to X Friday to apologize ...
Facebook · ABC7 News
430+ reactions · 1 day ago
Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff plans to halt software engineer hiring in 2025 due to AI productivity gains, while Klarna's CEO linked a 22% ...
Benioff apologizes for much-despised National Guard ...
SFGATE
https://www.sfgate.com › Technology
2 days ago — Marc Benioff, after saying the National Guard would help police San Francisco, has apologized. The recanting came after a story about ...
Salesforce told ICE it could help speed up hiring ...
Reddit · r/technology
260+ comments · 2 days ago
Benioff going full Trumper is an embarrassment for anyone working at Salesforce. Hope the cash is worth it for those who can afford to go ...
---
crc bs
The rest of Tides Foundation’s board consists of a number of development and legal experts from liberal foundations, government, and companies known for funding left-wing groups. One of these is Salesforce, a $4 billion cloud computing firm based in San Francisco. In 2015, Salesforce’s CEO, Marc Benioff, cancelled programs requiring employees to travel to Indiana after that state passed religious freedom legislation he considered “discrimination.” Meanwhile, Benioff saw no irony in his organization maintaining offices in communist China, a country the U.S. State Department classifies as “of particular concern” for jailing and torturing its religious citizens.